Back to blog
Market Trends
June 13, 2023

Legacy Modernization: The Pitfalls of Starting from Scratch and the Power of Upcycling

Legacy modernization is a critical endeavor for organizations seeking to adapt to changing business landscapes and embrace innovation. However, the complexities and risks associated with large, mission-critical applications often lead to project failures.

Dr. Ronny Schüritz
Table of Contents


In today's rapidly evolving technological landscape, many organizations find themselves burdened with large, mission-critical applications built on outdated technologies commonly referred to as legacy systems. These applications, while still serving essential functions, often hinder innovation, scalability, and overall operational efficiency. Legacy modernization becomes imperative to overcome these challenges and stay competitive. However, the process of modernizing such applications is notoriously complex, and many projects end up failing. This article delves into the difficulties associated with modernizing large, mission-critical applications and proposes an alternative approach known as upcycling, facilitated by a modern end-to-end development platform designed specifically for legacy application modernization.

The Challenge of Modernizing Large, Mission-Critical Applications

Modernizing large, mission-critical applications presents a myriad of challenges that contribute to the high failure rate of such projects. These applications often have years or even decades of accumulated functionality and business logic tightly woven into their codebase. Some common challenges include:

  1. Complexity: Legacy applications tend to be intricate, tightly coupled, and lacking in documentation. Understanding the underlying codebase and its interdependencies becomes a significant challenge, making it difficult to plan and execute a successful modernization strategy.
  2. Risk and Cost: Modernizing large, mission-critical applications inherently carries a significant amount of risk and cost. Organizations cannot afford to disrupt critical operations during the modernization process, as downtime or data loss can have severe consequences. Consequently, the fear of operational disruptions often leads organizations to postpone or abandon modernization efforts.
  3. Talent and Expertise: Finding skilled developers with expertise in legacy technologies can be challenging. Many developers today are more proficient in modern programming languages and frameworks, making it difficult to assemble a capable team for legacy modernization.

The Downfall of Rebuilding from Scratch

One common mistake organizations make when modernizing their legacy applications is attempting to rebuild them entirely from scratch. This approach often leads to project failures and cost overruns. Here are some reasons why rebuilding from scratch is problematic:

  1. Loss of Intellectual Property: Legacy applications often contain valuable intellectual property, including proprietary algorithms, business rules, and specialized functionality. Rebuilding from scratch risks losing this knowledge and can disrupt critical business processes.
  2. Scope Creep: Starting from scratch often leads to scope creep, as stakeholders tend to envision grandiose improvements and features during the planning phase. This can result in projects becoming overly complex, time-consuming, and ultimately unfeasible.
  3. Longer Timeframes: Building an application from scratch requires significant development efforts, including rewriting the entire codebase, migrating data, and retesting. This can extend the project timeline, increasing the chances of budget overruns and delayed delivery.

The Power of Upcycling

Rather than attempting to rebuild from scratch, organizations should consider the alternative approach of upcycling, enabled by a modern end-to-end development platform tailored for legacy application modernization. Upcycling involves transforming and revitalizing existing applications by leveraging the following strategies:

  1. Reusing Existing Database and Business Logic: Instead of discarding the existing application's foundation, upcycling allows organizations to reuse the valuable components, such as the database structure and business logic. This preserves the intellectual property and ensures continuity of critical operations.
  2. Leveraging Pre-built Parts of the Platform: A modern end-to-end development platform for legacy modernization provides pre-built components and modules that can be seamlessly integrated into the application. This eliminates the need to develop everything from scratch, saving time and effort.
  3. No-Code and Low-Code Tools: With visual designers and no-code/low-code tools, upcycling empowers developers and business users alike to rapidly develop and deploy new functionalities. These tools abstract the complexities of coding, enabling faster iterations and reducing the reliance on specialized legacy skill sets.


Legacy modernization is a critical endeavor for organizations seeking to adapt to changing business landscapes and embrace innovation. However, the complexities and risks associated with large, mission-critical applications often lead to project failures. Rebuilding such applications from scratch rarely yields the desired outcomes and can result in significant setbacks. Instead, organizations should explore the upcycling approach, leveraging a modern end-to-end development platform specialized in legacy application modernization. By reusing existing components, leveraging pre-built parts, and employing visual designers and no-code/low-code tools, organizations can achieve successful modernization while minimizing risks, reducing costs, and ensuring continuity of critical operations.

Build.One Document Generation

Build highly individual, data-driven and performant experiences.

  • Scale your document generation, collaboration and delivery
  • Integrate with your enterprise architecture
  • Design any layout and document structure
  • Fully customize your content management
  • Use the speed of No-Code or go fully custom with Pro-Code
Learn More

Schedule a Demo

Please fill out this form and we'll get in touch as soon as possible to schedule a demo with you.